The Protest Lab gallery is part of the museum's exhibition on the 1819 Peterloo Massacre. Image © People's History Museum

Controversy over PHM's removal of "adult human female" sticker

Geraldine Kendall Adams, 04.06.2019
Message taken down after complaints that it was "associated with hostility"
The People’s History Museum (PHM) in Manchester has found itself at the centre of a censorship row after it removed a sticker from its Protest Lab gallery, an interactive space that invites visitors to tell their personal stories of protest and share “ideas worth fighting for”.

The sticker read: “Woman, noun, adult human female. Sex is a protected characteristic – Equality Act 2010.” 

After retweeting a picture of the sticker, the museum later removed it from the gallery, saying: “We’ve been made aware that the sticker in this image we retweeted is associated with hostility… Any such images/material will be removed from the Protest Lab.”


The controversy stems from the increasingly divisive debate taking place between advocates for the trans community, who want trans women to have equal access to women's services and legal provisions, and gender critical feminists, who believe the law must make a distinction between biological sex and gender identity. 

A billboard featuring a similar message was taken down in Liverpool last year after complaints that it made trans women feel “unsafe and unwelcome”. 

The decision to remove the sticker led some commentators on social media to accuse the museum of censorship. One responded: “If by 'protest' you meant 'protest that no one disagrees with' you should have said so”, while another wrote: “You, the People's History Museum of all people, [deeming] the word woman as hostile and worthy of censorship, when the exhibition is about protesting and disrupting, is beyond parody.”

However, many commended the museum’s actions, with one saying: “Well done to the museum staff. Sorry you've got all this crap from people”, and another writing: “Proud that PHM has a long tradition of fighting transphobia AND supporting inclusive, intersectional feminism.”

The PHM said in a subsequent statement: “PHM supports trans rights and women’s rights. We recognise that there are many different perspectives on this subject, which we will always listen to and encourage debate around, as with all issues. Protest Lab is designed to be a space that invites thought and discussion, whilst being a welcoming space for all.”

The Protest Lab is part of the museum’s current Disrupt? Peterloo and Protest exhibition marking the 200th anniversary of the Peterloo Massacre in Manchester. 

Comments

Sort by: Most recent - Most liked
Anonymous
06.06.2019, 15:01
This is disappointing, and demonstrates that women face a spectrum of discrimination, including from some who should know better.
Anonymous
06.06.2019, 14:48
Looks like the MA is about to disappear up its own fundament with its obsession with "diversity", "equality", etc etc. The MA was set up as a professional body to support museum professionals in work with collections of all kinds but seems to have morphed into a political agency promoting elite liberal issues that are of no interest, if not positively offensive, to many museum workers who are sick of seeing their professional body abused as a vehicle for promoting LGBT propaganda. Since when was this - or indeed any other form of political agitation - the function of a museum?

Similarly (referring to your article on museums collecting anti-Trump memorabilia), although I am no fan of Trump, I do find it extraordinary that museums should see it as their duty to encourage protest against the elected leader of a friendly nation.

The British cultural world's turn to politics and its one-sided views on social matters and the arts have brought my 30-year career caring for collections and sharing them with a grateful public to an end and I am now looking for alternative employment where I don't feel constantly threatened by Political Correctness.